I had originally planned for this post to be politics oriented after Newt Gingrich won the SC primary. However, recent events have taken me off the panic button and I think I'll save that post for next week after Florida has cleared some things up.
So, what's as important as national politics? Or probably more important? Burgers.
 |
| In 'n Out Double Double |
 |
| Five Guys |
Two years ago a Five Guys moved into Dinkytown, and converted me into a fan of the occasional tweener burger. Better than the straight fast food (although IMO the new Wendy's burgers are very good for 100% fast food), and a bit more convenient than an actual great local burger place, most of which were in St. Paul, like The Blue Door Pub and The Nook. My standard was the Five Guys bacon double cheeseburger and an individual cajun fry. Good food, extremely unhealthy, and a touch on the expensive side ($9.04 for the burger and fries, although anyone who's eaten at Five Guys knows they go crazy on the fries).
Now that I'm in the Dallas/Plano area, I felt I owed it to myself to try In 'n Out. The western/southwestern/southern rival to Five Guys, and from all the comments I hear apparently an institution in this part of the country. Today I had the Double/Double (2 patties, 2 cheese slices), fries well done, and a Dr. Pepper.
The breakdown...
Burgers: Tiny Advantage Five Guys
I know, my first comparison is a hedge-your-bets. That's the fair rating for me though, as each had perks. 5 Guys has a ton of options with their burgers, but In 'n Out is just ridiculous.
More options than I'll ever eat. What I liked about In 'n Out was the thousand island sauce (a nice touch), the carmelized onions could come whole instead of chopped, and you could get the bun done extra toasted, to ward off burger juice. All nice features in my book. What I like about Five Guys is that the burgers seem a touch bigger, and bacon is a featured option. I do love bacon. Since the burger is the most important part of the comparison as a whole, this sets the stage for a close call. In 'n Out could take the lead if I'm ever stupid enough to order the 4x4. That just sounds like excessive fun (4 patties, 4 cheese slices).
Fries: Major Advantage Five Guys
I ordered a side of cheese fries well done at In 'n 'Out. They were a nice compliment to the burger. Cheese was hot and tasty, fries were very similar to McDonald's in texture, perhaps a bit crunchier since I went well done on them. Solid. Problem is for In 'n Out, I absolutely crave the cajun fries at Five Guys. It's not a contest. Cajun wins.
Drink Options: Major advantage In 'n Out
First, you can get a chocolate, vanilla, or strawberry shake at In 'n Out for the same cost as a large pop. You can also get combinations of any two or all three. Second, In 'n Out has Dr. Pepper, which has been my favorite pop for a decade with no close second, and Five Guys doesn't. Choice is clear.
Convenience & Fun Factor: Advantage Five Guys
Both places are a bit quirky in an 1950s diner sort of way, but I like the fact that Five Guys has a glass area where you can watch them cook your burger, and although I beat the giant line today by about five minutes, the In 'n Out I was at
did have a giant line form at 3:00 in the afternoon. That's ridiculous. Drive thru helps In 'n Out here, but that line was also crazy long. I don't like lines.
Price: Advantage In 'n Out
Meal with pop at In 'n Out today -- $6.71. Burger and fries at Five Guys -- $9.04. More fries at Five Guys, but still probably 20-25% more expensive.
My pick -- Five Guys by a nose. After all, my fridge is stocked with Dr. Pepper.